(845) 724-3031 mail@pepeinsurance.com

Make a Payment

During normal business hours, we gladly accept payments for you.

Many of our companies have direct online payment options such as paying with a credit card or signing up for Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) transactions. Many of them have an option to sweep directly from your checking account without even writing a check.

Below are links to our insurance companies direct payment websites. Click on the company name to be directed to their payment page. Please have your policy number available, to expedite your payment process.

Insurance CompanyPhone Number
Adirondack(877) 248-0555
American Collectors(866) 874-4794
Erie Insurance(800) 458-0811
Farmers(800) 597-2548
Foremost Star(888) 888-0080
Hagerty(877) 922-9701
Hanover(800) 573-1187
The Hartford(800) 423-6789
Kemper(877) 252-7878
Main Street America(800) 611-0958
Mid-Hudson Cooperative(800) 721-5001
Progressive(800) 876-5581
Safeco(800) 332-3226
Selective(888) 974-7400
Travelers(800) 550-7716
Tower Group(877) 883-6599